Meet Keri Nicholson

What Does Twenty Years in West Maui Change?

It changes what I notice, what I question, and what I believe you need to understand before buying or selling here. I’m Keri Nicholson, a REALTOR® Broker and luxury real estate specialist with 20 years of West Maui perspective. I combine local knowledge, honest advice, and a concierge-level approach to help clients make clear decisions in a market where the details matter.

Send Keri a Message
Book a Consultation
REALTOR® Broker

Keri Nicholson

Coldwell Banker Island Properties
License #: RB-24151

I’m Keri Nicholson, a REALTOR® Broker and Global Luxury Specialist with 20 years of West Maui perspective. I combine local knowledge, honest advice, and a concierge-level approach to help clients make clear decisions in a market where the details matter.

Send a message
Keri Nicholson

How Did West Maui Become Home?

I grew up in Topsfield, Massachusetts, where I learned the East Coast work ethic that still shapes how I approach my business. Preparation matters. Details matter. When someone trusts you with an important decision, you show up ready and follow through.

Maui offered a very different pace, but it never felt like a place where effort mattered less. It simply asked for a different kind of attention.

Before entering real estate, I worked as a premier concierge in West Maui. That role taught me how much people value someone who listens closely, understands the place firsthand, and can turn a broad request into a thoughtful recommendation. Guests rarely needed more information. They needed the right information for the experience they were trying to create.

Real estate became a natural extension of that work. The stakes were higher, the questions became more complex, and the relationships lasted much longer, but the foundation remained the same. Understand what the person is really trying to accomplish. Know the local details. Explain the choices clearly. Make the experience feel considered rather than transactional.

Explore West Maui

Which Community Fits Your Plans?

Explore Keri’s honest local guides to the communities she serves, with insight into lifestyle, ownership, rental considerations, and the property-level details that can shape your decision.

Client reviews

What Do Keri’s Clients
Say About Working With Her?

"Keri showed us numerous units of a very wide range of ownership structures, building types and locations. Her patience helped us find the unit perfect for our needs and preferences. We have been very happy with our purchase, 5 years and counting."
"Keri Nicholson is a superb realtor; knowledgable, honest & forthright. Keri is not only personable but thoughtful & easy to work with. She represented us well & looked out for our best interest. We highly recommend her to represent you, whether you are buying or selling properties on island."
"Keri is very helpful in all aspects of the purchase process. I have worked with Keri on two transactions and would use Keri again."
"Working with Ms Keri Nicholson was a great experience from start to finish. She and her team were knowledgeable and made the process stress free. We appreciated her guidance."
""My wife and I went to Maui April 2021, and we were looking to buy a condo on maui. We walked into the office of Keri Nicholson. That was a gift. Keri took the time to help us find a condo. She drove us around, picked us up at our resort and showed us several different areas and different units. We were doing a 1031 exchang…
"We had a great experience working with Keri on buying our place and eventually selling it many years later. She is professional, knowledgeable and fun to work with. We leaned on her knowledge of the island even in times we weren’t buying or selling. Can’t say enough good things about her and Highly recommend her to anyone l…
"I was in town for a business trip. I realized that I was going to have to come back and forth to get my office open. Hotel rentals were crazy high. I reached out to Keri and mentioned my dilemma to see what alternatives there were. Ended up purchasing a condo while on the plane :). You feel immediate trust, was always very…
"We had a great experience with Keri; we bought a condo / investment property that we rent out and use on trips to the island She was very helpful in identifying which parts of Maui we'd be interested in living (explaining the different climates, feel / culture, etc); she knows the market well; she also knows various proper…
"Keri listened to what we wanted. She showed us everything available that fit the bill. She found us a home that we all will enjoy for years to come. She’s a great agent and I’d hire her again and again."
"We so appreciate our friend and real estate agent Keri! As a fellow real estate agent in California, I needed a professional who is going to help me navigate the Maui real estate market. She found us the perfect condo that felt like our home away from home and we have spent many amazing moments there with our friends and fa…
Read More Client Stories

Is it a good time to sell?

How Much is your home really worth?

Let me provide you with a personalized, in-person valuation report. You'll receive an accurate, detailed analysis of your property's value, including insights into market trends and potential opportunities for improvement.

Get your home value